Latest News

Selection Criteria in Redundancy

Objectivity in a redundancy selection is a key element of fairness.  The criteria used to score “at risk” employees within a selection pool in order to decide who is made redundant should, as far as possible, be objective (eg attendance, disciplinary record) rather than subjective (eg attitude).  But can an employer ever go too far in their quest for objectivity?  Can insisting on entirely objective criteria with no recognition of past good performance actually render a redundancy procedure unfair? 

Yes said the Employment Appeal Tribunal in Mental Health Care v Biluan and Makati.  MHC applied a selection procedure that was more akin to a recruitment process than a redundancy process.  It was based on three factors: attendance record, disciplinary record and a competency assessment.  It was undertaken by managers who had not previously worked with the affected employees.  Length of service, past appraisals and past good performance were not considered.  As a result a number of good workers were selected for redundancy to the surprise of management who stuck by
the process and ultimately dismissed the lowest scorers.  The Tribunal found that the clinical process used was unreasonable and so unfair. 

When determining the criteria for a selection exercise employers should not only consider whether the criteria is objective but also whether the
process on the whole is reasonable.  Common sense and fairness should be applied even if this means allowing an element of justifiable subjectivity.    

For more information please contact Martin Sinclair or Nicola Gray or call 01224 632464. 


Latest News
Residential Property Quarterly Reflections and Insights

The latest quarterly report from the ASPC gives a reassuring picture of local market activity, with the house price index remaining, mostly, in the positive. The change in quarterly price is +1.5%, while the annual change is -0.5%. Taken over five years, the index is marginally positive at +0.4%. While the figures are reassuring, it may well be that our local market is yet to feel the strain of the general economic background and only time will tell whether this will be reflected in the remainder of 2023. Buyers’ wariness over the short term may well affect property sales as they effectively “sit tight” to see what happens with interest rates. This may result in a sluggish Autumn/Winter market as moving plans are put on hold, but for the moment, there is still healthy demand for properties in desirable locations and in good condition. 

Read More
Mackinnons Partners Gear Up for Ride the North

On Saturday 26th of August, Mackinnons Partners Neil Torrance, Pamela Bursill and Gregor Sim will be tackling Ride the North together with friends and family to raise money for local children’s charity “Charlie House”.

Read More